Examples of Formative and Summative Assessments in Various Disciplines
Formative Assessments
Math
Open
Formative Assessments: Math | ||
Category | Method | Description |
Collaborative and Interactive Learning Strategies | Think-Pair Share | Pose a problem related to a recent algebra concept (e.g., solving quadratic equations). Have students think individually, discuss with a partner, and then share with the class. |
Quick Polls | Use online polling tools (like Kahoot or Poll Everywhere) to ask multiple-choice questions about key concepts (e.g., properties of exponents). Review results immediately to address misconceptions. | |
Traditional Assessment Methods | Low-Stakes Quizzes | Administer short, ungraded quizzes at the beginning or end of class to check understanding of recent topics (e.g., factoring polynomials). Discuss answers in class to reinforce learning. |
Independent Practice and Reinforcement Assessments | Problem Sets | Assign regular homework problems covering recently taught material. Provide detailed feedback to help students understand mistakes and learn correct methods. |
Discussion-Based and Dialogic Activities | Guided Discussions | Facilitate discussions on how to approach complex algebra problems. Encourage students to explain their thought processes and strategies for solving equations. |
Collaborative and Peer-Assisted Learning | Group Problem-Solving | Have students work in small groups to solve challenging algebra problems. Each group presents their solutions to the class, followed by peer feedback. |
Peer Review of Homework | Allow students to exchange homework assignments and provide feedback to each other using a rubric. | |
Reflective and Process-Based Assessments | Learning Journals | Ask students to keep journals reflecting on their understanding of algebraic concepts, challenges, and plans to address those challenges. |
Technology-Enhanced Learning Assessments | Online Practice Platforms | Use tools like Khan Academy, ALEKS, or MyMathLab for students to practice algebra problems and receive instant feedback. |
History
Open
Formative Assessments: History |
||
Category | Method | Description |
Collaborative and Interactive Learning Strategies | Think-Pair-Share | Present a historical question or scenario (e.g., "What were the causes of the American Revolution?"). Students think individually, discuss with a partner, and share with the class. |
Quick Polls | Use online tools to ask students questions about recent lecture topics (e.g., key events of the Civil Rights Movement). Review results to address misunderstandings immediately. | |
Traditional Assessment Methods | Low-Stakes Quizzes | Administer short, ungraded quizzes at the start or end of class to check understanding of recent readings or lectures (e.g., key dates and figures of the French Revolution). Discuss answers in class. |
Independent Practice and Reinforcement Assessments | Document Analysis | Assign students primary source documents to analyze. Provide feedback on their interpretations and understanding of the historical context. |
Discussion-Based and Dialogic Activities | Guided Discussions | Facilitate discussions on significant historical events or themes. Encourage students to express their viewpoints and engage in debates, promoting critical thinking. |
Collaborative and Peer-Assisted Learning | Group Projects | Have students work in small groups to research and present on specific historical events or figures. Each group presents their findings to the class, followed by peer feedback. |
Peer Review of Essays | Allow students to exchange draft essays and provide feedback to each other using a rubric. | |
Reflective and Process-Based Assessments | Learning Journals | Ask students to keep journals where they reflect on what they learned from lectures, readings, and discussions, as well as their thoughts on historical interpretations and events. |
Technology-Enhanced Learning Assessments | Online Discussion Boards | Use platforms like Canvas to create discussion forums where students can discuss readings and lecture topics, allowing for ongoing engagement outside of class. |
STEM
Open
Formative Assessments: STEM |
||
Category | Method | Description |
Collaborative and Interactive Learning Strategies | Think-Pair-Share | Present a problem or concept (e.g., solving a physics equation, explaining a chemical reaction). Students think individually, discuss with a partner, and share with the class. |
Quick Polls | Use online polling tools to ask questions about recent lecture topics (e.g., properties of a material, steps in a biological process). Review results to clarify misconceptions. | |
Traditional Assessment Methods | Low-Stakes Quizzes | Administer short, ungraded quizzes at the start or end of class to check understanding of recent material (e.g., math problems, coding syntax). Discuss answers in class. |
Independent Practice and Reinforcement Assessments | Problem Sets | Assign regular problem sets that cover recently taught material. Provide detailed feedback on their solutions to help them understand mistakes and learn correct methods. |
Lab Reports | Assign small lab experiments where students must report their methods, observations, and conclusions. Provide feedback on their scientific reasoning and writing. | |
Discussion-Based and Dialogic Activities | Guided Discussions | Facilitate discussions on complex STEM concepts or current research findings. Encourage students to explain their thought processes and engage in scientific debates. |
Collaborative and Peer-Assisted Learning | Group Projects | Have students work in small groups to solve challenging STEM problems or conduct experiments. Each group presents their findings to the class, followed by peer feedback. |
Peer Review of Assignments | Allow students to exchange homework assignments or lab reports and provide feedback to each other using a rubric. | |
Reflective and Process-Based Assessments | Learning Journals | Ask students to keep journals where they reflect on their understanding of STEM concepts, what they find challenging, and how they plan to address those challenges. |
Technology-Enhanced Learning Assessments | Online Practice Platforms | Use tools like MyMathLab, CodeSignal, or MATLAB Grader, where students can practice problems and receive instant feedback. |
English Composition
Open
Formative Assessments: English Composition |
||
Category | Method | Description |
Collaborative and Interactive Learning Strategies | Think-Pair-Share | Pose a prompt related to a writing skill or concept (e.g., developing a thesis statement). Students think individually, discuss with a partner, and share their ideas with the class. |
Quick Polls | Use online tools to ask questions about writing techniques or grammar rules. Review results to clarify misconceptions immediately. | |
Traditional Assessment Methods | Low-Stakes Quizzes | Administer short, ungraded quizzes on grammar, punctuation, or citation styles. Discuss answers in class to reinforce learning. |
Independent Practice and Reinforcement Assessments | Writing Exercises | Assign short writing tasks focused on specific skills, such as crafting topic sentences or using transition words. Provide detailed feedback to guide improvement. |
Reading Responses | Have students write responses to assigned readings, focusing on analysis and personal reflection. | |
Discussion-Based and Dialogic Activities | Guided Discussions | Facilitate discussions on writing techniques, literary analysis, or rhetorical strategies. Encourage students to share their interpretations and engage in peer feedback. |
Collaborative and Peer-Assisted Learning | Peer Review Sessions | Have students exchange drafts of their essays and provide constructive feedback using a guided rubric. Focus on specific aspects such as organization, clarity, and argument strength. |
Group Writing Projects | Assign collaborative writing tasks where students work together to produce a piece, such as a group essay or research project. | |
Reflective and Process-Based Assessments | Learning Journals | Ask students to keep journals where they reflect on their writing process, challenges they face, and strategies they find helpful. |
Self-Assessments | Encourage students to evaluate their own work using a rubric before submitting their final drafts. | |
Technology-Enhanced Learning Assessments | Online Writing Labs | Use platforms like Purdue OWL or Grammarly for students to get additional writing help and instant feedback on grammar and style. |
Discussion Boards | Create online forums for students to discuss readings and share drafts for peer feedback. |
Humanities
Open
Formative Assessments: Humanities |
||
Category | Method | Description |
Discussion-Based and Dialogic Activities | Regular Class Discussions or Debates | Allow students to articulate their understanding and engage with diverse perspectives. Use open-ended questions to stimulate critical thinking and assess students' grasp of the material in real-time. |
Reflective and Process-Based Assessments | Reflective Journals | Students keep journals where they reflect on readings, lectures, and discussions. These reflections provide insights into their evolving understanding and personal connections to the material. |
Visual Graphic Organizers | Concept Maps | Students create visual representations of the relationships between key concepts. This helps identify misconceptions and provides a visual aid for understanding complex ideas. |
Collaborative and Peer-Assisted Learning | Peer Review | Students review and provide feedback on each other’s work. This encourages collaborative learning and helps students learn to critique constructively. |
Collaborative and Interactive Learning Strategies | Think-Pair-Share | During lectures, students first think about a question individually, then discuss it with a partner, and finally share with the larger group. Promotes active learning and helps instructors gauge understanding. |
Quick Writes and Reflection | Minute Papers | At the end of a class, students write briefly about what they learned and what questions they still have. Provides immediate feedback to the instructor about what concepts need further clarification. |
Business
Open
Formative Assessments: Business |
||
Category | Method | Description |
Applied and Contextual Learning Assessments | Case Studies | Regular analysis and discussion of business case studies allow students to apply theoretical knowledge to real-world scenarios. Assess students' problem-solving skills and their ability to connect theory with practice. |
Collaborative and Cooperative Learning Assessments | Group Projects | Students work in teams to complete projects related to business concepts. Assess collaboration, project management skills, and application of business principles. |
Experiential and Interactive Learning Assessments | Simulation Games | Business simulation games provide hands-on experience in managing a company. Instructors observe decision-making processes and strategic thinking in a controlled environment. |
Role-Playing | Students assume roles in business scenarios, such as negotiations or leadership positions. Assess communication, negotiation, and leadership skills. | |
Quick Writes and Reflections |
Quick Writes | At the beginning or end of class, students write a brief response to a prompt related to the day's lesson. Helps gauge their understanding and identify areas needing further clarification. |
Iterative Assessment |
Feedback Loops | Frequent opportunities for students to give and receive feedback on their performance in class activities and assignments. Encourages continuous improvement and active engagement. |
Media and Design
Open
Formative Assessments: Media and Design |
||
Category | Method | Description |
Reflective and Process-Based Assessments | Sketchbooks and Process Books | Students maintain sketchbooks or process books documenting their creative process, ideas, and development. Allows instructors to assess the evolution of students' work and their engagement with the design process. |
Collaborative and Peer-Assisted Learning | Critique Sessions | Regular peer and instructor-led critiques of student work. Provides immediate feedback and encourages students to refine their designs based on constructive criticism. |
Formative Progress Assessments | Writing In Progress Reviews | Periodic reviews of ongoing projects where students present their progress. Instructors offer guidance and assess how well students are meeting project milestones. |
Creative Thinking and Brainstorming Activities | Idea Generation Exercises | Quick, timed exercises to generate ideas or concepts for a design challenge. Helps assess students' creativity and ability to think on their feet. |
Visual and Design-Based Assessments | Storyboards and Mockups | Students create storyboards or mockups for media projects such as films, animations, or websites. Provides a visual representation of their planning and conceptualization skills. |
Reflective and Process-Based Assessments | Design Journals | Journals where students reflect on their design choices, inspiration, and the rationale behind their work. Helps assess their critical thinking and self-reflection abilities. |
The Arts
Open
Formative Assessments: The Arts |
||
Category | Method | Description |
Reflective and Process-Based Assessments | Process Journals | Students maintain journals documenting their creative process, reflections, and development of ideas. Helps instructors assess the evolution of their work and their engagement with artistic practice. |
Collaborative and Peer-Assisted Learning | Studio Critiques | Regular critique sessions where students present their work to peers and instructors for feedback. Provides immediate feedback and encourages iterative improvements based on constructive criticism. |
Peer Feedback | Structured sessions where students provide feedback on each other’s work. Encourages critical thinking and helps students learn to critique constructively. | |
Interactive and Experiential Learning Assessments | Workshops and Masterclasses | Participation in specialized workshops or masterclasses with guest artists. Allows for skill development and formative assessment through observation and feedback from experts. |
Performance Based Assessment | Rehearsal Observations | For performance-based courses like dance, music, and theatre, regular observations of rehearsals. Instructors provide real-time feedback on technique, interpretation, and overall performance. |
Visual and Process-Based Assessments | Sketches and Studies | Preliminary sketches, studies, or practice performances. Helps assess students' preparatory work and understanding of foundational techniques. |
Health Professions
Open
Formative Assessments: Health Profession |
||
Category | Method | Description |
Practical and Competency-Based Assessments | Clinical Skills Assessments | Regular assessment of clinical skills through simulated patient interactions or practical exams. Instructors provide feedback on technique, bedside manner, and procedural accuracy. |
Applied and Contextual Learning Assessments | Case Studies | Analysis and discussion of patient case studies in class. Helps assess students' ability to apply theoretical knowledge to real-world scenarios and develop critical thinking skills. |
Reflective and Process-Based Assessments | Reflective Journals | Students maintain journals reflecting on their clinical experiences, challenges faced, and learning points. Allows for self-assessment and deeper understanding of their professional development. |
Inquiry-Based and Experiential Learning Assessments | Problem-Based Learning (PBL) | Small group sessions where students work through clinical problems collaboratively. Promotes active learning and helps assess problem-solving and teamwork skills. |
Performance-Based and Competency Assessments | OSCE (Objective Structured Clinical Examinations) | Structured practical exams where students rotate through stations to perform specific tasks. Instructors can assess clinical competence in a controlled setting. |
Experiential and Interactive Learning Assessments | Simulations | Use of high-fidelity simulations to replicate real-life medical scenarios. Helps assess clinical decision-making and hands-on skills in a risk-free environment. |
Summative Assessments
Math
Open
Summative Assessments: Math |
|
Method | Description |
Comprehensive Exams | Design exams covering all major topics taught in the course, such as solving linear and quadratic equations, graphing functions, and systems of equations. |
Algebra Projects | Assign projects requiring students to apply algebraic concepts to real-world scenarios (e.g., analyzing the trajectory of a projectile or modeling population growth using exponential functions). Require a written report and a class presentation. |
Research Paper | Have students write a paper on the history and application of a specific algebraic concept or method (e.g., the development of quadratic equations and their applications in science and engineering). |
Cumulative Problem Sets | Assign a final set of problems covering the entire course material, ensuring students demonstrate comprehensive understanding of algebra. |
Verbal Explanations | Conduct one-on-one oral exams where students explain how they solve specific algebra problems, demonstrating understanding and ability to communicate mathematical reasoning. |
Departmental Exams | Use standardized algebra tests created by the department to ensure consistency in evaluating student performance across different sections. |
Real-World Problems | Present students with complex, real-world problems requiring application of multiple algebraic concepts. Assess their solutions and explanations in written form. |
Cumulative Portfolios | Require students to compile a portfolio of their best work throughout the course, including homework assignments, quizzes, and projects. Include reflective essays discussing their learning journey and growth in understanding algebra. |
History
Open
Summative Assessments: History |
|
Method | Description |
Comprehensive Exams | Design exams that include multiple-choice questions, short answers, and essay questions covering all major topics from the course (e.g., causes and impacts of World War II). |
Historical Research Projects | Assign projects that require students to research a historical event, figure, or theme in depth. Students present their findings in a written report and a class presentation. |
Research Paper | Have students write a research paper on a specific historical topic (e.g., the effects of the Industrial Revolution on urbanization). Require primary and secondary sources for a comprehensive analysis. |
Cumulative Assignments | Assign a final set of questions or a project that requires students to synthesize and apply what they have learned throughout the course. |
Verbal Explanations | Conduct oral exams where students discuss and analyze historical events, demonstrating their understanding and ability to articulate historical arguments. |
Departmental Exams | Use standardized tests created by the history department to ensure consistency in evaluating student performance across different sections. |
Historical Simulations | Present students with a historical scenario and ask them to role-play and make decisions based on historical context (e.g., simulating a debate in the Continental Congress). |
Cumulative Portfolios | Require students to compile a portfolio of their best work, including essays, document analyses, and projects. Include reflective essays where students discuss their learning journey and understanding of historical themes. |
STEM
Open
Summative Assessments: STEM | |
Comprehensive Exams | Design exams that cover all major topics taught in the course, such as solving complex equations, explaining scientific processes, or programming tasks. |
Research Projects | Assign projects that require students to apply STEM concepts to real-world scenarios (e.g., developing a software application, conducting an engineering design project). Require a written report and a class presentation. |
Research Paper | Have students write a paper on the development and application of a specific STEM concept or technology (e.g., the impact of nanotechnology in medicine). |
Cumulative Problem Sets | Assign a final set of problems that cover the entire course material, ensuring students demonstrate a comprehensive understanding of the subject. |
Verbal Explanations | Conduct one-on-one oral exams where students explain how they solve specific STEM problems, demonstrating their understanding and ability to communicate scientific reasoning. |
Departmental Exams | Use standardized STEM tests created by the department to ensure consistency in evaluating student performance across different sections. |
Real-World Problems | Present students with complex, real-world STEM problems that require the application of multiple concepts to solve. Assess their solutions and explanations in written form. |
Lab Practical Exams | Conduct hands-on exams where students perform experiments and interpret data in a controlled setting. |
Cumulative Portfolios | Require students to compile a portfolio of their best work throughout the course, including problem sets, lab reports, and projects. Include reflective essays where students discuss their learning journey and growth in understanding STEM concepts. |
English Composition
Open
Summative Assessments: English Composition |
|
Method | Description |
Essay Exams | Design exams where students write essays on given prompts. Assess their ability to construct arguments, use evidence, and demonstrate writing skills under timed conditions. |
Research Papers | Assign a research project where students develop a thesis, conduct research, and write a comprehensive paper. Require multiple drafts and a final presentation of their findings. |
Creative Writing Projects | Assign creative writing tasks such as short stories, poems, or personal essays. Evaluate based on creativity, coherence, and adherence to writing conventions. |
Analytical Essays | Have students write in-depth analyses of literary works, focusing on themes, characters, and stylistic devices. Provide guidelines for structure and argument development. |
Cumulative Writing Portfolios | Require students to compile a portfolio of their best work, including essays, research papers, and reflections. Include a reflective essay where students discuss their growth as writers. |
Verbal Explanations | Conduct oral exams where students discuss their writing processes, choices, and revisions. Assess their ability to articulate their strategies and understanding of writing concepts. |
Departmental Writing Tests | Use standardized writing assessments created by the department to ensure consistency in evaluating student performance across different sections. |
Real-World Writing Tasks | Present students with practical writing scenarios, such as crafting a business letter, writing a grant proposal, or creating a blog post. Assess their ability to adapt their writing to different contexts and audiences. |
Cumulative Portfolios | Require students to compile a portfolio of their best work throughout the course, including essays, writing exercises, and reflections. Include a reflective essay where students discuss their learning journey and growth as writers. |
Humanities
Open
Summative Assessments: Humanities |
|
Method | Description |
Essays and Research Papers | Students write in-depth essays or research papers on topics covered in the course. Assess students' ability to synthesize information, construct arguments, and engage in critical analysis. |
Exams and Quizzes | Mid-term and final exams, as well as periodic quizzes, evaluate students' knowledge and understanding of key concepts. Can include multiple-choice questions, short answers, and essay questions. |
Presentations | Students prepare and deliver presentations on specific topics or projects. Assesses their ability to communicate effectively and demonstrate their knowledge orally. |
Portfolios | Students compile a portfolio of their work throughout the course, including essays, projects, and reflections. Provides a comprehensive view of their progress and learning over time. |
Creative Projects | Depending on the course, students might complete creative projects such as artworks, performances, or digital media projects. Allow students to express their understanding in varied and innovative ways. |
Annotated Bibliographies | Students compile and annotate a bibliography on a specific topic, demonstrating their research skills and understanding of sources. Shows their ability to critically evaluate and synthesize scholarly work. |
Business
Open
Summative Assessments: Business |
|
Method | Description |
Business Plans | Students develop comprehensive business plans, including market analysis, financial projections, and strategic planning. Assess ability to integrate various business concepts and present a coherent, viable plan. |
Exams and Quizzes | Mid-term and final exams, as well as periodic quizzes, test students’ knowledge of key business concepts. Can include multiple-choice questions, short answers, and case-based questions. |
Research Papers | Students write research papers on specific business topics, demonstrating their ability to conduct thorough research and present findings. Assess critical thinking, research skills, and written communication. |
Presentations | Students present on business topics or project findings to the class. Assess ability to communicate effectively and demonstrate knowledge orally. |
Portfolios | Students compile a portfolio of their work throughout the course, including case analyses, projects, and reflections. Provides a comprehensive view of their progress and learning over time. |
Consulting Projects | Students work as consultants for real or hypothetical businesses, providing solutions to specific problems. Assess ability to apply business theory to practical problems and produce actionable recommendations. |
Peer Assessments | Students evaluate each other's contributions in group projects and activities. Encourages accountability and provides insights into teamwork and individual contributions. |
Media and Design
Open
Summative Assessments: Media and Design |
|
Method | Description |
Final Projects | Comprehensive projects that encompass the skills and knowledge gained throughout the course. Could be a completed design portfolio, a short film, an animation, or a website. |
Portfolios | Students compile a portfolio of their best work, showcasing their skills, creativity, and progression. Serves as a comprehensive assessment of their overall ability and readiness for professional practice. |
Exhibitions | End-of-term exhibitions where students display their work to peers, instructors, and sometimes the public. Assesses their ability to present and discuss their work in a professional setting. |
Written Reports | Reports accompanying design projects where students explain their design process, research, and final outcomes. Assesses their ability to articulate their work and its theoretical underpinnings. |
User Testing and Feedback | For interactive media projects, students conduct user testing and collect feedback. Assesses their ability to create user-centered designs and iterate based on feedback. |
Presentations | Formal presentations of their projects, including the design process, challenges faced, and final outcomes. Assesses their presentation skills and ability to effectively communicate their ideas. |
Digital Portfolios | Students create digital portfolios that can be shared online, often a requirement for design professionals. Assesses their ability to curate and present their work in a digital format. |
Research Papers | In-depth research papers on topics related to media and design theory or history. Assesses their research skills and ability to engage with theoretical concepts. |
The Arts
Open
Summative Assessments: The Arts | |
Method | Description |
Final Projects/Performances | Comprehensive final projects or performances that showcase students’ skills and creativity. Could be a solo exhibition, a dance recital, a music concert, or a theatre production. |
Portfolios | Compilation of students’ best work, demonstrating their skills, creativity, and progression. Serves as a comprehensive assessment of their overall ability and readiness for professional practice. |
Recitals and Exhibitions | End-of-term recitals for music students, exhibitions for visual arts students, and performances for dance and theatre students. Assesses their ability to present and discuss their work in a professional setting. |
Written Reports/Artist Statements | Reports or artist statements accompanying their projects where students explain their process, research, and final outcomes. Assesses their ability to articulate their work and its theoretical underpinnings. |
Auditions/Practical Exams | Practical exams where students perform or demonstrate their skills in a controlled environment. Assesses their technical proficiency and ability to perform under pressure. |
Digital Portfolios | Creation of digital portfolios for visual and performing arts students. Assesses their ability to curate and present their work in a digital format, often a requirement for professional practice. |
Research Papers | In-depth research papers on topics related to art, dance, music, or theatre history and theory. Assesses their research skills and ability to engage with theoretical concepts. |
Choreography/Composition Projects | For dance and music courses, students create original choreographies or compositions. Assesses their creativity, technical skills, and ability to produce original work. |
Performance Reviews | Students attend and review professional performances or exhibitions, analyzing and critiquing them. Develops their critical thinking and understanding of professional standards in their field. |
Health Professions
Open
Summative Assessments: Health Profession | |
Method | Description |
Comprehensive Exams | Mid-term and final exams covering theoretical knowledge and practical skills. Can include multiple-choice questions, short answers, and clinical scenario-based questions. |
Clinical Rotations | Assessment during clinical rotations where students work in healthcare settings under supervision. Evaluates their ability to apply knowledge in practice, interact with patients, and function as part of a healthcare team. |
Capstone Projects | Students complete a capstone project that involves research, clinical practice, or a combination of both. Assesses their ability to integrate and apply their learning to a significant project. |
Portfolios | Compilation of students’ clinical experiences, case studies, reflective journals, and other relevant work. Provides a comprehensive view of their progress and readiness for professional practice. |
Clinical Competency Exams | Exams specifically designed to test clinical skills and competencies. May include hands-on procedures, patient interviews, and diagnostic reasoning. |
Patient Care Reports | Detailed reports on patient care episodes, including diagnosis, treatment plan, and follow-up. Assesses their ability to document and communicate clinical information effectively. |
Research Papers | In-depth research papers on topics related to health professions, such as medical research, public health issues, or healthcare policy. Assesses their research skills and ability to engage with current issues in the field. |
Oral Exams | Oral exams where students are asked to discuss clinical cases, theoretical knowledge, and ethical dilemmas. Assesses their verbal communication skills and depth of understanding. |
Standardized Patient Interactions | Interactions with actors trained to portray patients with specific conditions. Assesses their ability to perform patient assessments, make diagnoses, and communicate effectively. |
Practical Skill Tests | Hands-on tests of specific practical skills, such as suturing, phlebotomy, or administering injections. Ensures proficiency in essential clinical procedures. |